Royal sub to visit SA
A Royal Navy nuclear submarine, HMS Sceptre, is to conduct an informal visit to Simon's Town, the SA Navy announced on Monday.
"The visit forms part of the British High Commission's aim of promoting diplomatic relations with South Africa and will further strengthen the existing relations between the SA Navy and the Royal Navy," said navy spokesperson Lieutenant-Commander Prince Tshabalala.
The ship's crew would also participate in various sporting events during their short visit to South Africa, starting on Thursday.
The submarine will not be open for public viewing but the media is invited to take pictures of the submarine at the Simon's Town SA Naval Dockyard.
The HMS Sceptre is manned by a crew of 114 (18 officers and 96 crew) and is 82,9m in length, with a beam of 10m and a draught of 9,4m.
The submarine would be in country until October 6, Tshabalala said.
Source: Independent Online
Informed Forum Post: Amatola Performance Has Been "Satisfactory"
According to the saairforce.co.za forum, the SAS Amatola performance during the exercises with the Royal Navy has been jugded "satisfactory":
[...]
Satisfactory is extremely good for a first time visitor I would have thought.
I believe it goes Just Satisfactory, Very Satisfactory, Satisfactory, Good
Before JSAT is not even worth talking about and is like a fail
[...]
Source: saairforce.co.za forum
Navy Lark — With A Deadly Serious Mission
(Dated 22 July 2007)
There is no time to move the dead body on the bridge as an enemy fighter jet shrieks towards the ship. The SAS Amatola heels violently to port as the aircraft roars 50m overhead, and officers yell “Brace! Brace!” moments before the bombs strike. Bang! Bang! Smoke billows from the starboard side of South Africa’s most potent warship, giving more desperate work to emergency teams already fighting three fires and a flood below decks.
And the bedlam continues on a grand scale outside as one Chilean warship and two British frigates churn up the ocean to fend off the same jets, missiles — and even one submarine — which have been attacking the South Africans for hours. Having spent controversial billions on its new world-class warships, the navy this week made its bid for training to match, in the waters south of Britain. Like the “dead body” on the bridge, the missiles weren’t real, simulated by fast aircraft diving at the ship and electronic pods attached to their wings which look like incoming rockets on the screens of the Amatola’s warfare operators. But the stress for the crew was as real as the stakes for the Amatola, which is seeking to become the first South African warship in 50 years to “officially qualify for war” on August 2, after a five-week training programme in Plymouth, south-western England.
Certification would make the Amatola — the first of the four corvettes purchased in the R44- billion arms deal — eligible for inclusion in multinational naval task forces for the first time, and the training is now to be taken back to Simon’s Town, Cape Town. It’s so comprehensive that, this week, professional actors will pretend to be villagers, stricken by a tsunami and the Amatola crew will rush to shore to rescue them. It’s so intensive that at the height of another mock battle, one damage-control officer, Chief Sandy Saunders, muttered, “We’re too tired to panic.” And it’s so expensive that Vice-Admiral Refiloe Mudimu, Chief of the South African Navy, refused to disclose the precise cost, despite estimates of “millions” by British veterans, and repeated questions from the Sunday Times.
The great mock battle in the English Channel this week – called The Thursday War – confronted the vessel’s crew of 117 with their most brutal test yet. Captain Guy Jamieson, commander of the ship, said the “real war” experience of the Royal Navy trainers had raised his crew’s skills to “a whole new level”. He said a week’s gruelling battle against an “enemy” submarine — loaned by the French navy — had been “the first real anti-submarine warfare practis ed by our navy for 22 years”. But he said it was the little lessons of the Royal Navy’s war experience that were having the greatest impact.
And so the crew of the Amatola has learnt that Formica table tops can splinter into dangerously sharp shards when broken up on impact; that nylon uniforms melt against the skin in severe heat. In the murky ops centre in the bowels of the ship, operators manning the bank of electronic warfare consoles — so secret that “we can’t even talk about it” — did a strange thing when the “Brace! Brace!” command came in, as another jet simulated an attack. They all lifted their feet off the ground, stretched their heads to one side, closed their eyes, and stayed in that bizarre position until the all-clear was called. “That,” said Warrant Officer Michael Kritzinger, “is to protect them from flying glass from their consoles, a lesson learnt the hard way by the Royal Navy in combat.”
Rather than computer-simulated drills, Britain’s Flag Officer Sea Training organisation attached the Amatola to a real task force of five warships, and pitted a force of real fighter jets, surface ships and a submarine against its warfare team. Meanwhile, an on-board training team simulated damage from the hostile force, while also sabotaging the ship’s systems at crucial moments in the battle. Sneaking around the vessel’s gangways like gremlins in white overalls, the “wreckers” tossed smoke bombs into cabins, strapped gruesome-looking wounds onto sailors’ limbs, and taped announcements to computer consoles, declaring failures which operators would have to fix or work around. Before the war, wreckers briefed Mudimu, who visited the ship for the event. One said: “We’re going to leave exposed explosives on deck — a broken rocket. In wartime, very simple: you should throw it overboard. We’ll see what the crew does.”
Later, Mudimu told the Sunday Times that the money spent on the corvettes would have been “wasteful” without top- level training in war and humanitarian scenarios. “We didn’t come here as a clean slate, but the British navy has been involved in real war situations, so the value of their experience is very important for us,” said Mudimu. “The South African economy depends upon its sea lanes being free [from threats]; we need assets to safeguard our riches at sea, so we are able to trade freely. “Also, we have commitments to Africa and the [Southern African Development Community] region. Mozambique has a coastline as long as ours, but what has it got to protect it? Namibia is in a similar position. ”
Earlier, Petty Officer Derrick Vadevale, manning a machine gun attached to the flight deck, had seconds to choose good guys from bad, as various small craft rushed towards the side of the ship. He “opened fire” on one as a “terrorist threat” when a man suddenly stood up with an RPG rocket launcher on his shoulder. Another speedboat driver escaped “death” when he turned out to be “a trainer playing a drunk guy just wanting to take a look at the ship”. Vadevale, a 34-year-old gunner from Durban, said the terror attack on the USS Cole in 1999, in which a speedboat packed with high explosives rammed the warship, posed a new kind of threat to modern navies, which the British emphasised heavily in their training. “You have to know when not to engage, but you have to watch them carefully — there are dozens of ski boats and curious people cruising around warships in harbours all the time; you never know,” he said.
Admiral Richard Ibbotsen, head of the training programme in Plymouth, said the Amatola crew had been on “a steep learning curve”, but “if you judge the ship’s capabilities over these past short weeks, the progress has been remarkable”. The goal of The Thursday War was for the Amatola and her three fellow warships to enforce a fake UN arms embargo and protect a large resupply vessel from attack by a fictitious rogue state called “Ginger”. Wreckers told Jamieson that the ship’s performance had been judged “satisfactory”. But at the end of the drama —- signified by a PA announcement that “threat levels have gone from red to white; all positions [stand down]; hoods off” — no one seemed to know whether the Amatola had won the war or not. For combat officer Lieutenant Letasha Maree, though, finishing the exercise, after a 70-hour week, was sweeter than victory. She said: “Jis, I just want a shower.”
HMS Edinburgh in Cape Town
The Royal Navy Destroyer HMS Edinburgh (D97) arrived in Cape Town yesterday and is moored at the V&A Waterfront until 21 November when she will depart for Simons Town.
On board was Lynx HAS.3S XZ229 (EB/411) from 815 Sqn, Edinburgh Flt, RN, Yeovilton. Incidentally, this Lynx is reputed to be the second oldest Lynx in RN service, with over 30 years service. There is only 300 hours left on the airframe and so it will, in all likelihood, be retired next year.
The Super Lynx 300 has been chosen by South Africa for operation with 22 Squadron, SAAF, aboard the new Valour Class frigates and the first of four ordered will be arriving in South Africa early next year.
In order to prepare for the arrival of the new aircraft, personnel from HMS Edinburgh will be aboard SAS Amatola while the Lynx will perform numerous approaches and landings in order to prepare the Amatola crew and develop operational procedures and doctrines.
Read more at: saairforce.co.za
RN ship visiting Cape Town
HMS Edinburgh arrived in Cape Town this morning and will be staying for a week before conducting a passage exercise with SAS Amatola on the 21st November, which will include flying the RN Lynx helicopter.
Navy must work to fight 'bad men' at sea
The world's navies had to work ever more closely together to combat "bad men" at sea, the First Sea Lord of Britain's Royal Navy said in Pretoria on Monday.
"There are bad men at sea: whether they are pirates... crooks... smuggling drugs... smuggling people... terrorists, this is an international issue we have to work together on," said Admiral Sir Jonathon Band.
He was meeting the Chief of the SA Navy, Vice-Admiral Johannes Mudimu, during a week-long visit to South Africa.
The SA Navy was an important partner because of its new capabilities - through its new corvettes and submarines - and its role in Africa.
Read more at: Independent Online
SA Navy gets helping hand
A new team from Britain's Royal Navy is due in South Africa next month to help train South African Navy officers to work in new ships and submarines, the Chief of the South African Navy, Vice-Admiral Johannes Mudimu, said on Monday.
The United Kingdom's First Sea Lord, Admiral Sir Jonathon Band, is currently on a week-long official visit in South Africa.
The Royal Navy have been training South African Navy officers for the past 18 months on what Band described as ways to bring together man and ship.
"It basically ... makes a crew that can steam the ship properly, look after it, fight fires, deal with natural disasters [and] start to build on integration of weapons system and sensors," Band said.
The training is part of efforts to keep the South African Navy on par with the rest of the world, Mudimu said.
"So we are very proud of the quality of training and support and financial support that the Royal Navy is providing the South African Navy," Mudimu said.
One of the officers trained in Britain is Captain Bravo Mhlana, who is due to take over command of the corvette the SAS Isandlwana. He will be the first black African to command a warship in the South African Navy.
"We got a bilateral agenda so that we can see bring the South African Navy along in the brotherhood of world navies, being an absolute crucial part off it," Band said.
Read more at: Mail & Guardian Online
New book: 'Three Frigates' - The South African Navy comes of age 2
For nearly two decades the three President Class frigates acquired by the SA Navy in the 1960s dominated the South African maritime scene. These three ships - President Kruger, President Steyn and President Pretorius were ordered from Britain in the 1950s in compliance with the requirements of the so-called Simon's Town Agreement.
In this book we find out not only about the ships themselves but also some of the political background at the time of purchase that led to their acquisition and for the first time we can read of some of the political background twenty years later that led to them being sidelined whilst still in 'their prime' and very useful ships.
We also find out how the SA Navy developed from 1953 when 'we were a 'mickey mouse' outfit' to 1963 when 'we were a pretty professional set up and able to hold our own with the Royal Navy'. Considerable comment is also given in various sections of the book on some of those areas where the author believes that National, SADF and/or SAN policies or procedures hindered the proper operational manning and deployment of these fine ships.
For the first time in a book on the SA Navy the full story of how the Navy became part of the so-called 'Border War' during Operation Savannah and what the President Class frigates achieved in that operation is told.
The main story of this book is not about the tragic loss of SAS President Kruger on 18 February 1982, however this important occurrence in the history of our Navy does get serious attention and the author does try to explain what happened, hopefully in terms that the non-naval reader will also understand. He also gives some reasonably detailed comment, especially on the official findings of the formal inquest into the death of one of her ship's company as a result of that accident.
There are also many other happier stories from the time of their building in the UK, and on a number of diplomatic visits made by them to Argentina, Australia and Europe. Then there are visits to our own harbours and such incidents as entertaining 'Snow White, the seven Dwarfs and some twenty chorus girls' onboard the President Kruger, and other stories about the multitude of different characters who served in these beautiful ships over the years, some strange, some tragic, but mostly amusing.
The previous Chief of the Navy, Vice Admiral Johan Retief, whilst still in that post agreed to write a foreword for the book, and had the following comment on it:
" I found the draft compelling reading and, from my knowledge, an excellent history of a most important phase of the Navy's history. There are clear lessons to be learnt, stretching from how to man ships properly to how to name ships. ... It is essential that these lessons be retained for future generations as we move back into a large ship era. " and "Conclusion. To repeat myself, I think you have done remarkably well. I have read the draft for contents only and not for style, I am not qualified to do that. I presume that you are discussing the matter with an editor. I enjoyed that the fact that you interspersed the factual history with anecdotes, it keeps one interested. Well done. BZ"
Note: BZ, or Bravo Zulu phonetically, is 'navalese' for 'Well done' and was inked in by hand. It originates from the NATO book of two letter signal codes and means 'Well done'.
This book can be ordered at: Just Done Productions

